For the December NYC’s Secrets & Lies storytelling show at the South Street Seaport Museum, I baked 300+ cookies for our guests. All the recipes had a historical backstory and a maritime connection to match the theme of our show and the beautiful venue.
I’ve gotten messages asking for the recipes and the stories behind them, so here they are! Swipe through the photos to find the recipe cards and the history behind each cookie.
I hope you enjoy baking up a bit of NYC history with:
– The Captain’s Lie (New Amsterdam Lemon Jumbles)
– Sweet Corruption (Spiced Molasses Gingerbread)
– The Original Hustle (Dutch Shortbread Trefoils a la the Girl Scouts)
Since it’s cookie season, I’d love to see your baking pics! Happy baking! 
Christa Avampato 