My friend, Amy, sent me a link to a The 99% Declaration put together by the members of Occupy Wall Street. After reading through it carefully, I understand what they’re looking for as well as their goal. And now I know for certain that I am not a part of their 99%. I’m not a part of the 1% either. I guess I am on my own, which is where I’d prefer to be.
Here is the link to the Declaration if you’d like to read it: https://sites.google.com/site/the99percentdeclaration/. Here are my concerns with it:
1.) I don’t like that they are suggesting that as an individual I would not be able to donate to the candidates’ campaigns whose ideals I support. I think that’s infringing upon my own individual freedoms.
2.) Many people in this country have retirement savings in 401Ks, IRAs, etc. that are made up of mutual funds and stock holdings. To say that I can’t have those savings if I or anyone in my immediate family holds public office is again infringing upon my rights to financially care for my future. Exactly what am I supposed to do with those holdings if I or someone in my immediate family decides to run for office?
3.) I am all for healthcare reform and change but single payer healthcare seems like a very scary thing to propose is such a sweeping gesture. Our healthcare system is quite complex and there are many countries with nationalized healthcare who are unhappy with their system as well. In the end, doctors actually don’t have to take insurance at all and wealthy individuals will just pay out-of-pocket for the best care, likely to the best doctors who would no longer be a part of the healthcare system because they couldn’t afford to practice in a single payer system. We’d run into the similar issue we have with public versus private education.
4.) Why should free market corporations subsidize all student loans? Individuals choose which debts to take on – I certainly did and I am responsible for those choices. There are deferment programs already in place which I have taken advantage of at times when I was not employed so I’m not sure why they think that is not an option.
5.) The recall of military personnel is based upon a great deal of top-secret information that we are not privy to for our own safety. While I do want the troops to come home, I also want to make sure that all of their efforts don’t fall apart and that our national and global security is not further jeopardized in the process.
6.) In general, our economy is moving toward more skills-based roles and away from manufacturing. Tom Friedman wrote an excellent article on this topic today that lays out his opinion on how to transform our economy: Imagined in America.
7.) They are implying the passage of embargoes against certain nations like China who manipulate their currency. This would be disastrous for our country, particularly in this recession. Again, Tom Friedman addressed this idea in his column today.
8.) The bank regulation they are proposing around lending does not allow financial institutions to take risk into account to make good business decisions. In short, if someone has a low credit score then it is tough to justify that banks should give them loans at a very low rate. What if they again cannot repay the debt they take on? Who pays then if banks couldn’t appropriately price for risk in granting the loan? I also think they don’t fully understand how regulated the banking system has become in the last few years since the recession hit full force. Much of that regulation is a very good thing but the side effect has been that it is much harder for those in lower socioeconomic brackets to get any credit.
9.) I absolutely think that they should form their own party and run candidates in elections. YES! Their last point all but says that this is what they intend to do. I think that’s a great idea and I hope they follow through with it. This is the way to have them voice their concerns about the system and become a part of participatory government, as well as to see the complications that are inherent in running an incredibly complex political, economic, and social system.
Get in the game Occupiers and don’t wait until July 2012. Now is the time to make yourselves heard and for others to consider your proposals in the upcoming election season.







